November 19, 2026
By Ahmed Saeed
The International Commission of Jurists (ICJ) has said Pakistan’s 26th and 27th Constitutional Amendments have effectively undermined the independence of the judiciary, allowing other branches of the state to exert decisive influence over the courts and impairing their ability to protect fundamental rights.
In a report titled Judicial Capture: Independence of the Judiciary in Pakistan after the 26th and 27th Constitutional Amendments, the international legal body said the cumulative impact of the amendments and their implementation had deprived the country’s higher judiciary of institutional safeguards required under international law.
The report concluded that the changes had resulted in “systemic judicial capture by other branches of the State” and had weakened the courts’ ability to serve as a check on the executive and legislature.
“The effect of the 26th and 27th amendments and the manner in which they have been implemented is that the higher judiciary of Pakistan no longer enjoys the institutional guarantees of independence required under international law and standards,” the ICJ said.
The organisation said the amendments marked a departure from the judicial independence framework that had emerged following the restoration of the judiciary in 2009.
While acknowledging concerns over judicial overreach and the Supreme Court’s interference in the affairs of other institutions, the ICJ said Parliament had failed to address those concerns through reforms compatible with judicial independence.
“Instead, the 26th and 27th amendments have led to systemic judicial capture by other branches of the State and the dismantling of the rule of law in the country,” it said.
The report alleged that the ruling coalition had used public dissatisfaction with the judiciary’s functioning to pursue changes that enabled greater control over the institution.
“As a result, even the highest courts of the land in Pakistan no longer serve as a check on the executive or the Parliament, and their function as avenues for redress of victims of human rights violations is seriously impaired,” it added.
Changes to judicial appointments
The ICJ traced the erosion of judicial independence to changes introduced through the 26th Amendment, which altered the composition of the Judicial Commission of Pakistan (JCP), giving parliamentary and executive representatives a greater role in judicial appointments.
Under the amended framework, judicial members were reduced to a minority in the commission, while members of the legislature and representatives of the executive became part of the appointment process. The amendment also introduced a parliamentary committee empowered to select the Chief Justice of Pakistan from among the three senior-most Supreme Court judges.
The report said the new composition of the JCP gave the government a decisive role in judicial appointments, particularly because the commission was not required to publicly disclose the criteria or reasons for its nominations.
It noted that the commission’s proceedings remained opaque, leaving the public without an explanation of how candidates were shortlisted or selected.
The ICJ also criticised the appointment process for the Federal Constitutional Court (FCC), established under the 27th Amendment, saying its judges were appointed almost entirely through executive selection, with limited involvement of the judiciary.
The report said no public criteria or reasoning had been provided to explain why certain judges of the Supreme Court and high courts, as well as a retired judge, were selected for the FCC while others with recognised constitutional expertise were not.
It also referred to the resignations of Supreme Court Justices Syed Mansoor Ali Shah and Athar Minallah following the enactment of the 27th Amendment, noting that the departures reflected concerns within the judiciary over the changes.
Concerns over transfers and accountability of judges
The report raised concerns over the powers introduced through the 27th Amendment allowing the JCP to recommend the transfer of high court judges between provinces without their consent.
It said the amendment did not provide clearly defined criteria or objectives for such transfers, creating a risk of interference with judicial independence.
The ICJ referred to the transfer of three Islamabad High Court judges in April 2026, including Justice Mohsin Akhtar Kayani, Justice Babar Sattar and Justice Saman Rafat Imtiaz, following recommendations by the JCP.
It also cited Justice Kayani’s resignation in October 2026, which was linked to concerns over the growing influence of the executive over the judiciary.
The report further criticised the introduction of “inefficiency” as a ground for removal of high court judges under the 26th Amendment, arguing that the term had not been defined and could be applied arbitrarily.
It said the absence of a clear threshold for determining inefficiency could expose judges to disciplinary action for conduct falling short of serious incompetence, including the time taken to decide complex cases.
FCC’s handling of politically significant cases
The ICJ also examined the Federal Constitutional Court’s performance since its establishment, raising concerns about its handling of politically sensitive matters.
It said the court had used jurisdictional disputes, delays, deferrals and the disposal of cases on technical grounds to avoid deciding constitutionally significant questions on their merits in a timely manner.
The report also expressed concern over the FCC’s use of its constitutional powers to assume jurisdiction over cases involving constitutional interpretation, saying the practice raised questions about whether the court was pre-empting potentially unfavourable decisions against the government.
Among the cases examined was the FCC’s intervention in proceedings relating to the jurisdiction of the Peshawar High Court following the imposition of an emergency in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa in October 2026.
The report said the FCC suspended proceedings before the Peshawar High Court concerning the exercise of its writ jurisdiction and protection of fundamental rights, including petitions challenging preventive detention orders, pending its interpretation of the constitutional provisions governing the high court’s jurisdiction during the deployment of the armed forces in aid of civil power.
ICJ calls for review of amendments
The ICJ urged the government to initiate a comprehensive review of the 26th and 27th Constitutional Amendments and their implementation in light of Pakistan’s international obligations, particularly under the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR).
It called for transparent and broad public consultations as part of the review and recommended that the government seek technical assistance from the UN Special Rapporteur on the independence of judges and lawyers and invite the rapporteur to visit Pakistan.
For the Judicial Commission of Pakistan, the report recommended revising judicial appointment criteria in accordance with international standards and ensuring that published criteria were the sole basis for nominations to the Supreme Court, FCC and high courts.
It also called for transparent appointment procedures and the publication of reasons for judicial nominations, as well as clearly defined criteria for transfers between high courts. The ICJ urged the commission to refrain from recommending transfers without the consent of the judges concerned.
The report further called on the Supreme Judicial Council to define “inefficiency” in a manner consistent with international standards, limiting it to serious incompetence that renders a judge unfit to discharge their duties.
It also urged the Special Parliamentary Committee responsible for selecting the chief justices of the Supreme Court and FCC to adopt clear and transparent criteria and procedures and publish reasons for each selection.
The ICJ called on the FCC, Supreme Court and high courts to interpret and apply the provisions of both amendments, to the greatest extent possible, in a manner consistent with judicial independence guaranteed under Article 14 of the ICCPR.