November 03, 2026
Staff Report
LAHORE
Six United Nations human rights experts have told the Government of Pakistan that its decision to proscribe the Azad Jammu and Kashmir Joint Awami Action Committee (JAAC) as a terrorist organization may violate international law. They suggest the group was targeted because of its political, labour and human rights campaigning.
In a 14-page allegation letter (reference AL PAK 4/2026), the UN experts in Geneva say they are “concerned that the designation may not be consistent with international standards concerning terrorist listings, and that JAAC may have been unjustifiably listed in retaliation for its political, labour and human rights advocacy, in violation of international human rights law.” The letter was made public recently on its website.
The letter, dated September 4, 2026, was signed by the Special Rapporteur on human rights while countering terrorism, Ben Saul; the Chair-Rapporteur of the Working Group on Arbitrary Detention, Ganna Yudkivska; and the Special Rapporteur on extrajudicial, summary or arbitrary executions, Morris Tidball-Binz. The other signatories are the Special Rapporteurs on freedom of expression, Leopoldo Maldonado Gutiérrez; on freedom of peaceful assembly and of association, Gina Romero; and on human rights defenders, Andrea Bolaños Vargas.
A coalition turned ‘proscribed organisation’
According to the letter, JAAC is “a coalition of traders, lawyers, transport workers and civil society activists” in Azad Jammu and Kashmir. It campaigns on governance, public services, electricity tariffs, employment, land rights and political representation, and has organised public demonstrations since 2023.
On 5 June 2026, the AJK Home Department issued a notification designating JAAC a “proscribed organization” under the First Schedule of the Anti-Terrorism Act 2014. The notification alleged that the group was engaged in terrorism and had created anarchy “by intimidating the public and promoting insecurity.”
The experts highlight the timing and context. The designation coincided with the start of nominations for elections scheduled for 27 July 2026. It also followed calls by JAAC for a region-wide strike, after its campaign to abolish the 12 legislative assembly seats reserved for refugees from Indian-administered Kashmir was rejected by the Supreme Court. The territory’s Prime Minister publicly welcomed the ban as the “end of mob rule” and said the group’s protests amounted “to terrorism and anti-State acts.”
The letter also notes that authorities had dealt with JAAC as a legitimate interlocutor until days earlier. Documents show that the regional and federal governments “formally engaged with JAAC representatives for the past years and signed formal agreements with them,” including the Muzaffarabad Agreement of October 2025. As recently as 28 May 2026, JAAC representatives received a written invitation from the Chief Secretary’s office to a 30 May discussion on non-AJK constituencies in the Legislative Assembly.
Terror listing fails international standards
The experts say they do not wish to prejudge the accuracy of the allegations. Still, they set out several reasons why the designation appears hard to reconcile with international law.
No explanation of the criteria
The designation rested on allegations of “terrorism, anarchy and intimidating the public.” The experts say, however, that “no explanation has been provided as to how those allegations satisfy the criteria for designation under international human rights law,” and that neither the conduct attributed to JAAC nor the evidence relied upon has been identified.
The international test
Drawing on reports by the Special Rapporteur on countering terrorism, the letter says the criteria for listing must be “clearly established by law and publicised,” and based on a properly defined concept of terrorism. There must be “reasonable grounds, based on credible and convincing evidence,” that an entity meets those criteria, and an organization “should only be listed where it has the substantial purpose of engaging in terrorist offences.” Even then, designation must remain necessary and proportionate, which includes showing that less intrusive measures, “such as surveillance or criminal investigation, would be ineffective.”
Failure under national law
The experts say “it has not been adequately explained how conduct by members of JAAC meets the definition or statutory criteria for proscribing organizations under national law.” They add that the legal framework itself is flawed. In their view, both the grounds for proscription under section 11B of the Anti-Terrorism Act and the definition of terrorism in section 6 “do not meet international standards.”
They call the definition “vague and overbroad,” saying it covers “a variety of conduct that is not genuinely terrorist in nature,” and say the listing procedure “does not accord sufficient due process.” They point to earlier analysis in communication PAK 1/2025 and to the UN Human Rights Committee’s 2024 call for Pakistan to ensure that its definition of terrorism is “clear and precise” and complies with “the principles of legality, legal certainty and predictability.”
Necessity and proportionality
Even if JAAC had met the statutory criteria, the experts say it was “not demonstrated why its designation was considered necessary.” Nor was it shown whether “less restrictive measures directed at any individuals suspected of criminal conduct were considered,” or how the resulting restrictions met the tests of “necessity, proportionality and individualised application.”
Missing procedural safeguards
Organizations facing listing should be promptly told the factual basis, legal consequences and available remedies, receive enough disclosure to challenge the decision, and have “access to prompt and effective judicial review.” The experts say JAAC “does not appear to have been informed of the factual basis for its designation,” and that it is “unclear whether it has access to an independent and effective mechanism to seek delisting or prompt judicial review.”
Rights to protest, associate and participate
A central strand of the letter is that the listing appears to punish the lawful exercise of civil and political rights. The experts say the designation “may involve the misuse of counter-terrorism powers in response to activities that appear to involve the exercise of the rights to freedom of expression, peaceful assembly and association and the right to take part in public affairs,” protected by articles 19, 21, 22 and 25 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, which Pakistan ratified in 2010. They add that this appears to be the case “rather than conduct demonstrated to constitute terrorism.”
They recall that restrictions on these rights must be authorized by law and be strictly necessary and proportionate in pursuit of a legitimate security aim. In their words, “the exercise of these rights cannot, without sufficient justification, be equated with terrorism or subjected to counter-terrorism measures.”
They warn that the listing could “contribute to narratives of stigmatization and criminalization which are especially harmful during election periods.” Counter-terrorism powers, they say, “must not be used to suppress” these rights or to restrict civic space and the legitimate activities of civil society groups, human rights defenders, journalists or political opponents.
Deaths, arrests and communications blackouts
The letter also details alleged violations after the designation. A planned “long march” from Rawalakot to Muzaffarabad, intended to demand accountability for earlier killings and the release of detainees, was prohibited. Some 4,000 police and paramilitary personnel were deployed. Security forces allegedly used tear gas and batons and also “lethal force to prevent protesters from advancing, with live ammunition killing dozens of protesters and wounding many more.”
At least 96 protesters have reportedly been killed since June 2026, along with six police and paramilitary personnel. Many of the dead were between 15 and 35 years old. The experts report that families “have reportedly had to sign documents claiming that the victims were terrorists in order to have the bodies released.”
At least 70 people, including JAAC members and supporters and journalists, were arrested, and some face criminal proceedings, including on terrorism charges. The response also involved internet and mobile restrictions, curfews “in apparent collective punishment,” hospital shutdowns and denial of medical care to injured protesters.
The experts express “grave concern” at the reported excessive force and recall that “firearms should never be used simply to disperse an assembly,” and that intentional lethal force is lawful only where “strictly unavoidable to protect another life from an imminent threat.”
They add that the use of tear gas and batons “appeared to be unnecessary and disproportionate and may have even amounted to torture.” They also stress the duty to investigate all potentially unlawful deaths “promptly, effectively, thoroughly, independently, impartially and transparently,” in line with the Minnesota Protocol.
205 people placed on 4th Schedule list
The experts are also “alarmed” that 205 people, including women, have been placed on the Fourth Schedule of the Anti-Terrorism Act. They have reportedly had their identity documents cancelled or suspended, which blocks access to services including medical care. Their bank accounts and passports are said to be frozen, and they must report any movement to the police. The experts recall earlier concerns that listing and delisting under the Fourth Schedule “does not meet requirements under international human rights law,” and say they “renew these concerns.”
Explanation sought from govt
The experts say it is their responsibility to “seek to clarify all cases brought to our attention,” and ask the Government to respond on eight matters. They first invite any additional information or comment on the allegations, and then ask for the legal and factual basis for designating JAAC, “including the conduct and evidence relied upon and how the designation satisfies the criteria for terrorist listing under international human rights law.”
They also want to know what procedural safeguards and remedies are available, including notification, disclosure of reasons and access to judicial review or delisting, and what measures have been taken to ensure that the designation and related counter-terrorism measures do not unnecessarily interfere with freedom of expression, assembly and association, participation in public affairs and the right to defend human rights.
The UN experts further ask what steps have been taken to investigate alleged violations of the right to life, injuries from law enforcement operations, arbitrary detention, and restrictions on communications and media reporting.
In addition, they seek details of the measures adopted so that JAAC members and supporters can exercise their rights, including training and other steps to prevent excessive use of force during peaceful protests, and of those adopted to guarantee that JAAC can promote and defend economic, social and political rights “free from the fear of reprisals.”
Finally, the experts ask for the factual and legal basis for placing the 205 individuals on the Fourth Schedule’s list of “proscribed persons,” the administrative and judicial appeals open to them, and how the measures are consistent with international law.
The communication, and any reply, will be made public on the UN communications website after 60 days, or earlier if the Government responds sooner. Both will also appear in a subsequent report to the Human Rights Council.
Meanwhile, the experts urge Pakistan to take “all necessary interim measures” to halt the alleged violations and prevent their recurrence, and to ensure accountability for those responsible if investigations bear out the allegations.
The Working Group on Arbitrary Detention may separately transmit the case through its regular procedure to determine whether detentions were arbitrary. The Government is required to respond to the allegation letter and the regular procedure separately.
The experts also note that Pakistan replied to an earlier communication, PAK 1/2025, on 9 February 2026. The experts, however, “regret not having received a response” to several others communications, including PAK 17/2025, PAK 5/2025 and PAK 8/2024.
