Voicepk.netVoicepk.netVoicepk.net
Font ResizerAa
  • News
    • National
    • Punjab
    • Sindh
    • Khyber Pakhtunkhwa
    • Federal Territory
    • Gilgit-Baltistan
    • Balochistan
    • Azad Jammu Kashmir
    • World
  • Exclusive Shows
    • Frontline Pakistan
    • Rights Watch
  • In Focus
    • Opinion
    • Features
    • Webinars
  • Climate Watch
  • Exclusives
    • Documentaries
    • Rights Guide
  • Events
    • AJCONF
    • Other
  • About Us
    • AGHS Legal Aid Cell
    • Our Team
    • Contact
  • اردو ویب سائٹ
Reading: Effective Regulation Needed Instead of a Social Media Ban for Children Under 16; Providing a Safe Digital Environment is the Responsibility of the State and Social Media Companies: Speakers
Share
Font ResizerAa
Voicepk.netVoicepk.net
  • News
  • Exclusive Shows
  • In Focus
  • Climate Watch
  • Exclusives
  • Events
  • About Us
  • اردو ویب سائٹ
Search here....
  • News
    • National
    • Punjab
    • Sindh
    • Khyber Pakhtunkhwa
    • Federal Territory
    • Gilgit-Baltistan
    • Balochistan
    • Azad Jammu Kashmir
    • World
  • Exclusive Shows
    • Frontline Pakistan
    • Rights Watch
  • In Focus
    • Opinion
    • Features
    • Webinars
  • Climate Watch
  • Exclusives
    • Documentaries
    • Rights Guide
  • Events
    • AJCONF
    • Other
  • About Us
    • AGHS Legal Aid Cell
    • Our Team
    • Contact
  • اردو ویب سائٹ
Follow US
Federal TerritoryNEWSUncategorized

Effective Regulation Needed Instead of a Social Media Ban for Children Under 16; Providing a Safe Digital Environment is the Responsibility of the State and Social Media Companies: Speakers

At a special Voicepk.net Spotlight debate in one of Islamabad's schools, 78% of students voted against an under-16 social media ban—urging lawmakers and tech giants to focus on regulation and safety rather than isolation. Key points were raised regarding a proposed blanket ban.

13 Min Read

November 14, 2026

By Fauzia Kulsoom Rana


ISLAMABAD

A debate has mushroomed in Pakistan regarding a ban on social media use for children under 16, children. Lawmakers, digital rights experts, and child protection organizations have emphasized that instead of completely keeping children away from social media, there is a need to provide them with a safe digital environment, hold social media companies accountable, and implement effective laws and regulations.

A special debate on this crucial topic was organized at a private school in Islamabad under Voicepk.net’s program “Spotlight,” hosted by renowned journalist Munizae Jahangir. Students aged 14 to 16 participated in the discussion, while an audience of nearly 150 children was given the opportunity to express their opinions and ask direct questions to policymakers.

The central theme of the debate was whether children under 16 should be allowed to use social media. Online polls were also conducted among the children before and after the debate to gauge their opinions.

Panelists included Ayesha Raza Farooq, Chairperson of the National Commission on the Rights of Child (NCRC); PML-N Senator Dr. Afnan Ullah Khan; Usama Khilji, digital rights activist and Director of Bolo Bhi; and Dr. Mehak Naeem, a researcher in child protection and health and Director of Programs at Pehchan.

Opening the discussion, host Munizae Jahangir noted that the debate over banning social media for children under 16 had moved from the Senate to the Punjab Assembly. She recalled that the matter was first raised in the Senate in July 2025 by Senators Sarmad Ali and Masroor Ahsan, followed by a resolution passed in the Punjab Assembly.

She emphasized that when policies and laws concerning children are being drafted, the voices of the children whose lives will be directly impacted by these decisions cannot be ignored.

Referring to the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child—which Pakistan ratified in 1990—Munizae Jahangir stated that children hold fundamental rights to freedom of expression, access to information, and recreation. The real question, she said, is how to strike a balance between protecting children and upholding their fundamental rights.

Support for Effective Regulation Over a Blanket Ban

Ayesha Raza Farooq clarified that the National Commission on the Rights of the Child does not support a complete ban on social media for children under 16, though this does not mean platforms do not require stricter regulation.

She stated that other effective methods exist to keep children safe and that Pakistan should formulate policies based on its own ground realities and institutional capacities rather than copying models from other countries. She stressed the need for comprehensive national research on children’s social media usage, its positive and negative impacts, online harassment, and other risks so policymakers can make evidence-based decisions.

Farooq added that the primary responsibility for child safety should rest with digital media platforms. Platforms must display age-appropriate content, immediately remove harmful material, and hold perpetrators of online crimes accountable. Highlighting threats such as cyberbullying, grooming, and online blackmail, she said children must be provided an environment where they can approach their parents, teachers, and relevant authorities without fear.

Identifying Flaws in the Existing Online Child Protection System

Dr. Mehak Naeem observed that despite experiments with social media bans in various countries, efforts are still underway globally to build safe digital environments, legal frameworks, and institutional capacity.

She noted that while Pakistan has laws and institutions—including the National Cyber Crime Investigation Agency (NCCIA), the Pakistan Telecommunication Authority (PTA), and other regulatory bodies—the real need is to make these institutions effective, increase their resources and human capacity, and improve reporting mechanisms.

Pointing out that research shows children frequently face online harassment on platforms like Snapchat and WhatsApp, Dr. Naeem argued that banning only a few platforms will not solve the problem. She questioned how Pakistan could expect to replicate the outcomes of bans in developed countries without a strong reporting system, institutional capacity, and law enforcement. She advocated for a multi-pronged strategy encompassing digital literacy, parental training, the role of schools, institutional capacity-building, and necessary legal amendments.

Social Media Companies Prioritize Profit, Not Child Safety: Senator Afnan Ullah Khan

Senator Dr. Afnan Ullah Khan stated that the primary goal of social media companies is profit, not child protection. He stressed the need to understand the business models of Meta, Google, Snapchat, and other tech giants, as their platforms operate on algorithms designed to keep users engaged for as long as possible.

He noted that children’s use of certain games and digital platforms sometimes turns into addiction, making it essential to protect them from online dangers and the commercial interests of tech companies. Supporting restrictions on unsupervised social media access for children, Senator Khan suggested that parents set screen-time limits and establish monitoring systems. He emphasized that a single measure is insufficient; rather, legislation, parental supervision, and societal responsibility must work together.

Key Questions Raised Over Children’s Data and Fake Accounts

During the discussion, student Hamza Nadeem asked Senator Afnan Ullah Khan how authorities would ensure that adults do not access children’s platforms using fake identities if separate accounts are created for minors. He also raised data privacy concerns, asking what guarantees would prevent the misuse of personal information collected for age verification.

In response, Senator Khan stated that legal and policy-level work is underway in Pakistan regarding data localization and management in local data centers, noting that global tech companies have reservations about data storage requirements in the country. He agreed that age verification is a major challenge and that self-declaration of age by users is not enough.

Ayesha Raza Farooq added that discussions with Meta are exploring various AI-based age-detection methods, though privacy concerns surrounding facial recognition and age verification systems must also be taken into account.

Children Ask: Why Ban Children Instead of Punishing Criminals?

A pivotal moment in the debate came when student Talha Abubakar asked why children’s access to social media is being restricted instead of holding online perpetrators accountable. He questioned why the state does not utilize its cyber surveillance, IP tracing, and other technical capabilities to identify and punish criminals—a question that drew loud applause from the audience.

Agreeing with this stance, Ayesha Raza Farooq said that instead of penalizing children, digital platforms and offenders must be held accountable through the removal of harmful content, legal action against perpetrators, and safer platform algorithms.

Usama Khilji stated that a social media ban would strip affected children of their digital rights while allowing actual criminals and platforms to escape accountability. He remarked that banning children from social media is tantamount to shifting the state’s responsibility onto the children themselves, urging the state to act against criminals and harmful activities rather than excluding youth from the digital world.

Preparing Children for the Digital World, Not Isolating Them

Endorsing Usama Khilji’s views, Dr. Mehak Naeem described a complete ban as a limited and ineffective strategy that places the entire burden of safety on children. She stressed the need to teach digital literacy to children while training parents and teachers to better understand online activities and risks.

She added that schools must foster safe environments where children can report cyberbullying, harassment, or blackmail without fear and be connected with relevant authorities. She also called for closing legal loopholes and introducing reforms to address harmful content generated through artificial intelligence.

Social Media Also Educates Children About Global Issues

Student Hanzala Ali raised an important question during the session, asking how children would stay informed about major world events, gender inequality, and ongoing humanitarian crises if they were kept off social media. She noted that many young people learn about global issues and human rights violations through these platforms.

Responding to her, Senator Afnan Ullah Khan said the state does not have unlimited resources and that child protection is a shared responsibility among parents, society, and the state.

However, Usama Khilji disagreed, arguing that the state must prioritize the protection of its citizens, particularly children, and that with political will, it can mobilize resources to safeguard them. He added that since more than half of Pakistan’s population consists of children and youth, state systems should be child-friendly and structured around their needs and rights.

A Student’s Question: Why Not Make Social Media Safe Instead of Banning It?

Student Momina Farrukh pointed out that the debate should not center on whether children under 16 should be allowed to use social media, but rather on how social media can be made safe for them.

Ayesha Raza Farooq responded that this is the crux of the entire debate, reiterating the need for age-appropriate content, prompt removal of harmful material, action against offenders, and an effective complaint mechanism.

Addressing the students directly, she urged them not to remain silent if a private or objectionable photo is accidentally shared and used to blackmail or harass them. She noted that the Government of Pakistan, in collaboration with Meta, has launched the “Take It Down” portal, where victims, including children, can confidentially request the removal of harmful images or content from Meta platforms. She encouraged children to confide in their parents and teachers, warning that silence in the face of a mistake only invites greater danger.

Poll Results: 78% of Children Vote in Favor of Social Media Access

At the conclusion of the debate, Munizae Jahangir shared the results of both polls with the students:

  • Pre-debate poll: 78% voted in favor of allowing children under 16 to use social media, while 22% opposed it.
  • Post-debate poll: 78% continued to support access to social media, while 21% voted against it.

Munizae Jahangir noted that the results show a clear majority of children favor retaining access to social media, while also recognizing the need for effective regulation to keep it safe. She added that the most significant takeaway from the event was that lawmakers and policymakers listened directly to children’s perspectives, giving young people a platform to voice their questions and concerns.

Overall, participants emphasized that rather than curtailing children’s fundamental rights to information and freedom of expression in the name of protection, digital platforms must be held accountable, decisive action must be taken against online crimes, and a coordinated strategy must be forged among parents, educational institutions, and the state. The core message of the debate was that isolating children from the digital world is not a permanent solution; instead, they must be empowered to participate in it safely and responsibly.

Elections 2024: First Kalash man to contest for general seat in the KP assembly
Ahmadis face widespread restrictions on Eid prayers, escalating persecution
BYC slams police action against protest camp in Quetta
Protest erupts as 123 trees transplanted for parking plaza at Lahore’s historic Nasser Bagh
Disconnected & Silenced: Balochistan’s ongoing digital crisis
Share This Article
Facebook Email Print

Follow Us

OUR SOCIALS
Facebook Twitter Instagram Youtube Tiktok Whatsapp

Journalism for Human Rights in Pakistan

Voicepk.net

About Us

Voicepk.net is Pakistan ‘s first digital media platform dedicated to investigating, reporting & broadcasting human rights and legal issues happening in the country.
Read More...

Quick Link
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Our Team
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
© 2026. All Rights Reserved by VoicePk.net
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Username or Email Address
Password

Lost your password?