May 23, 2025
By Iqra Manzoor
LAHORE
A local court in Sukkur has issued a directive to the police to register a First Information Report (FIR) and initiate a formal investigation into the alleged underage marriage of 11-year-old Areeba to Syed Attaullah Shah. The court underscored that if the girl is indeed a minor, as substantiated by the documents presented, the marriage—even if claimed to be consensual—could constitute a serious offense under Pakistan’s rape laws.
The FIR was lodged by Areeba’s father, who is hearing and speech impaired. According to his statement, Areeba went missing from their home on the evening of May 2. Unable to communicate verbally, he alerted his brothers, Abdul Jabbar and Abdullah, via video call about her disappearance. Despite their efforts, the family was unable to trace Areeba until reports emerged of her alleged marriage in Hyderabad.
Following failed attempts to get the police to register the FIR against unknown individuals, the complainant turned to the court for relief. He maintains that his daughter was abducted and forcibly married, and has demanded the arrest and court production of all those involved.
Muhammad Siddique, has been abducted by some police officials, and nobody knew about her whereabouts. We believe police officials were complicit, which is why we filed a petition in court. As a result, the police were compelled to inform the court about Areeba’s location. It was during the court proceedings that the police produced the nikkah documents, and we first learned about her marriage.”
He further added, “We have all the documents proving that Areeba is a minor. She is only 11 and a half years old.”
Sohail also claimed, “The police had been trying to dodge the investigation before we filed the petition in the court. It was only after the court’s pressure that the police revealed the Nikkah of the girl, who is a minor.”
In response to the court’s earlier notice, reports were submitted by the DSP Complaint Cell Sukkur and the SHO New Pind Sukkur. These reports claimed that Areeba had entered into a free-will marriage with Syed Attaullah Shah in Hyderabad. The couple also reportedly sought protection from the Hyderabad Sessions Court, alleging threats from family members and staging demonstrations in their defense.
However, in a detailed and decisive judgment, the Sukkur court ruled that police reports do not bind judicial proceedings. The court clearly stated that even if the SHO reported the marriage as consensual, this does not override the legal implications of Areeba being a minor. Citing Section 375(v) of the Pakistan Penal Code (PPC), the judgment reaffirmed that sexual relations with a minor, even with alleged consent, amount to rape under the law.
The order stated: “Per settled law, the police report is not binding on the court, and after forming its own independent opinion, it is stated that the applicant, the father of the girl, has disclosed facts of a ‘cognizable offence’. Even if the report of the SHO considers that the girl has contracted a free-will marriage, the documents provided clearly establish that the victim Areeba is only 11 to 12 years old. In that case, the marriage of a minor under the age of sixteen years is itself a crime. As per Section 375(v) of the PPC, rape with the consent of a minor would also constitute the offence of rape.”
Concluding that the facts presented point to a cognizable offense, the court ordered the police to record the complainant’s statement under Section 154 of the Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC) and carry out a comprehensive investigation. The judgment further authorized the SHO to proceed under Section 182 PPC against the complainant if the documents provided are found to be false.
A video made by the couple is also circulating on social media, in which the girl claims she married Syed Attaullah Shah of her own free will. She refutes the documents presented in court, alleging they are fake and asserting, “I am 18 years old. I have appeared in the 9th-grade examinations and am currently studying in 10th grade.”
She further appeals to the authorities, stating, “I request the judge and the SP to ensure our protection. My husband and his family are facing threats from my father, Muhammad Siddique, my uncles Abdul Jabbar and Abdullah, and their sons. Please allow us to live peacefully and happily. We have been in a relationship for the past five years. I am not a minor. I am 18 years old.” However, the Nikkah Nama provided to Voicepk by the lawyer of the applicant, Muhammad Siddique Panhwar, father of Areeba suggests another story as it stated that the year of marriage of Siddique Panhwar is 2012.
Sub-inspector Zeenat told Voicepk, “We are investigating the case,” but refrained from sharing further details.
As the investigation unfolds, the case continues to raise critical questions about the enforcement of child protection laws, the role of law enforcement agencies, and the credibility of official documentation in cases of alleged underage marriage. With conflicting narratives from the family, the police, and the girl herself, the court’s intervention has brought the matter into sharp legal focus. The outcome of the police investigation—now under judicial oversight—will be pivotal in determining the course of justice for Areeba and assessing potential lapses or complicity within the system meant to protect vulnerable children.
