October 13, 2026
By Hashir Ahsan
ISLAMABAD
The Supreme Court has rejected all archaic and patriarchal ‘anti-women’ customs such as Ghag, Swara, and Watta Satta, dismissing the review petition of convict Kamran, who murdered a girl for refusing a marriage proposal, and upholding the death penalty.
Justice Muhammad Hashim Khan Kakar authored and issued the nine-page judgment.
In the judgment, the court stated that the rejection of a marriage proposal does not lessen the severity of the crime; rather, it aggravates it further.
This action was not the result of any sudden, grave, and immediate provocation, because the accused was merely aggrieved that the proposal he sent was not accepted. Such grief and anger cannot be accorded the status of mitigation that would reduce the death penalty prescribed under the law. The court termed it the result of an ego-driven impulse of men in our society.
In its decision, the Supreme Court also shed detailed light on the historical and social roots of male ego, honor-based systems, and violence against women.
The court held that the determination of sentence is a judicial discretion that must be exercised by taking into account the nature of the act, the manner of its commission, the helplessness of the victim, and the message sent to society by the criminal justice system.
Murdering someone simply because she rejected a marriage proposal is an extremely severe crime, said the court.
To highlight the trauma of women falling victim to such atrocities around the world, the court also quoted the words of Inteha Bibi published in ‘The Guardian’ (19 December 2023): “I have no life, I suffer from trauma and anxiety, and I cannot sleep without medication. I am a human being and I have full right to engage and marry according to my own will. I am a woman, not an item or a toy, and I do not want to forcibly marry anyone.”
The court wrote in the verdict that it is a matter of severe embarrassment for the conscience of any civilized society when a man, failing to gain a woman’s love or attention, responds with violence instead of accepting her refusal. He takes her life solely to satisfy his bruised ego. Marriage is a mutual and voluntary contract in which the free consent of both parties is mandatory.
However, in various patriarchal systems, it is assumed that a man possesses ownership rights over a woman without her consent.
When a woman exercises her fundamental right to say “no,” the man considers it an attack on his “honour,” resulting in stalking, house invasion, acid attacks, or femicide.
The court also mentioned the ironical and cruel customs prevalent in Pakistan and other countries. The judgment referenced the custom of “Ghag” found in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, where a man asserts his claim over a woman without her or her guardians’ consent by firing shots outside her house or through a public announcement, leaving the girl’s marital status hanging in limbo.
Against this custom, under the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Elimination of Custom of Ghag Act 2013, it has been declared a cognizable and non-bailable offense. Similarly, “Swara” (or Vani / Badal-i-Sulh) was mentioned, where an innocent girl is given in marriage to the opposing party as compensation through a Jirga decision for a crime committed by a man in her family, which has been criminalized under the Criminal Law Amendment Act 2004 and the Prevention of Anti-Women Practices Act 2011.
Furthermore, mentioning the custom of “Watta Satta,” the court noted that women are used as commodities rather than autonomous human beings.
The court also clarified that such oppressive behaviors are not limited to Pakistan alone; customs such as “Ala Kachuu” (bride kidnapping) in Central Asia and “Telefa” in the African region also reflect male dominance and coercion. Quoting renowned anthropologist Gayle Rubin’s 1975 essay “The Traffic in Women,” the judgment noted how historically women were viewed as gifts, currency, or items of exchange among men, and despite modern times, the mindset remains in men’s minds that a woman’s consent is subordinate to male privilege.
The court emphasized that in Islam, a marriage without the free consent of a woman is not valid. Whether male or female, every adult individual enjoys the complete right as to when, where, and with whom to marry. This is not a favor granted by society, but their personal and inherent right. Islam and international treaties such as ‘CEDAW’ (Article 16) give women the full right to the free choice of a spouse.
The court held that the accused in the present case also appears to be a victim of the same flawed mindset that a woman is a commodity, that the buyer or seeker has a right over her, and that there is no room for refusal. Declaring a woman’s lawful refusal as “provocation” or a mitigating factor is an extremely absurd and baseless argument, as no person has the right to take another’s life over the rejection of a marriage proposal.
Accepting such an argument would judicially endorse the notion that a woman’s consent is subject to male preference. The court concluded that no mitigating factor exists in this case; rather, it is an extremely severe and serious crime to which the principle of life expectancy does not apply at all.
While reviewing the prayer to commute the death sentence to life imprisonment on the principle of life expectancy, the court referred to the recent judgment in ‘Sher Afzal v. The State’. The court explained that the benefit of life expectancy cannot be provided blindly or indiscriminately to every death row prisoner. For a death row prisoner to obtain the benefit of this principle, three fundamental conditions must be met
First, the prisoner has spent at least 25 years behind bars.
Second, compelling mitigating circumstances exist in the case.
Third, the nature of the crime does not fall into the extremely severe or most aggravated category.
In its order, the court detailed the legal distinction between a prisoner serving life imprisonment (Lifer) and a condemned prisoner sentenced to death. The court stated that in the eyes of the law, both cannot be placed in the same category, nor can they be compared merely on the basis of time spent in prison.
A person awarded life imprisonment enters jail initially with a sentence of life imprisonment, which amounts to around 14 or 15 years owing to various remissions, whereas a death row prisoner enters with a sentence of death. Therefore, a death row prisoner cannot claim as a matter of right that after serving 14 or 15 years in jail, he stands on equal footing with a lifer.
The record shows that the accused Muhammad Kamran was arrested on September 5, 2012, and has spent only 14 years in prison, which is far less than the required period of 25 years; hence, he is not eligible for the benefit of life expectancy.
The court completely rejected the argument of treating the rejection of a marriage proposal as a mitigating circumstance, calling it erroneous, unreasonable, and unacceptable.
Background
According to the background of the case, the petitioner Muhammad Kamran was accused of murdering Maimoona Shaheen by shooting her inside her house. The prosecution established that the accused harbored enmity against the deceased because the deceased and her family had severed or rejected the marriage proposal sent by the accused. On this basis, the trial court sentenced the accused to death under Section 302(b) of the Pakistan Penal Code and ordered the payment of compensation.
Later, the High Court also confirmed the death sentence, and the Supreme Court dismissed the accused’s appeal through its judgment dated May 16, 2025, after which the accused filed a review petition in the Supreme Court.
In this review petition, the petitioner’s counsel, Basharatullah Khan, took the position that the petitioner had spent approximately 15 or 16 years imprisoned in a death cell; therefore, his sentence should be commuted to life imprisonment on the basis of the principle of life expectancy in light of established Supreme Court precedents.
Furthermore, defense counsel argued that since the rejection of the marriage proposal by the deceased and her parents was a personal and emotional event that incited the accused to take this step, this motive should be accepted as a mitigating circumstance and the death sentence be commuted to life imprisonment. He contended that these matters were not covered in the May 16, 2025 judgment, necessitating a review of the decision.
During the hearing of the case, Additional Prosecutor General (APG) Punjab Tariq Siddique assisted the court, while law clerks Muhammad Qasim Najam and Tayyaba Muneer also assisted the court. The hearing was completed on September 21, 2026.
In its judgment, the court clarified the scope of its review jurisdiction under Article 188 of the Constitution of Pakistan and Order XXVIII of Part IV of the Supreme Court Rules 2025, stating that a review petition cannot be made a medium for a second appeal or for reopening already settled matters. Unless the petitioner points out a clear, patent error or legal defect from the record, the court cannot interfere with its previously rendered judgment.
The court held that since all submissions had been carefully examined in the judgment under review and there was no legal or jurisdictional defect, no case for review was made out.
For all these reasons, the Supreme Court held that the petitioner failed to prove any error or defect within the limited scope of review under Article 188 of the Constitution. Therefore, this review petition is dismissed and leave to appeal is refused.
