October 16, 2026
Muhammad Danial
PESHAWAR
The imposition of an emergency and Governor’s Rule in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (KP) on October 11 has triggered a debate over fundamental rights, freedom of expression, the right to protest and the powers of elected representatives. Legal experts are divided on its implications, while opposition parties have challenged the move in the Peshawar High Court (PHC), which will hear the petitions on October 20.
The federal government invoked Article 232 of the Constitution, which allows the declaration of an emergency, and Article 234, which provides for federal intervention when constitutional machinery breaks down in a province. The move effectively transfers the provincial government’s administrative powers to the Governor.
Legal experts divided
Ahmed Farooq Khattak, a member of the Judicial Commission of Pakistan and Vice-Chairman of the KP Bar Council, said the protection of fundamental rights and civil liberties was the central issue. He maintained that the exercise of governmental authority during an emergency must remain consistent with the Constitution’s guarantees to citizens.
Supreme Court advocate Nadeem Shah said the move had raised concerns about civil liberties and the public’s access to their elected representatives. He warned that the arrest of protesters and the curtailment of elected representatives’ powers could make it difficult for citizens to take their grievances to the appropriate forums.
However Additional Advocate General Daniyal Chamkani offered a different view. He argued that in areas affected by conflict or ongoing security operations, the exercise of fundamental rights may already be restricted. But, he said Governor’s Rule did not extinguish citizens’ fundamental rights, which they continue to hold.
PTI links move to minerals dispute
Shandana Gulzar, a leader of the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI), claimed that the KP government’s refusal to sign an agreement on mines and minerals led to the imposition of Governor’s Rule and the emergency. The claim has not been independently verified. Doing so would require examining the agreement, official documents, and the positions of both the federal and provincial governments.
Petitions in the PHC
PTI Chairman Barrister Gohar Ali Khan has asked the PHC to declare the emergency and Governor’s Rule unconstitutional. His petition names the federal government, the President, the Prime Minister, the Governor of KP and other authorities as respondents.
A second petition was filed by Mohsin Dawar and Bushra Gohar, the central and provincial presidents of the National Democratic Movement (NDM), respectively. It describes the proclamation as “purely and patently against the mandate of people of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa” and therefore liable to be set aside.
The petitioners ask the court to declare the President’s October 11 proclamation without legal effect and jurisdiction, and to set aside all directions, appointments and actions taken under it. They also seek interim relief suspending the proclamation until the petition is finally decided.
The petitioners argued that the President, under Article 42 read with the Third Schedule, had a constitutional duty to preserve, protect and defend the Constitution and to keep personal interests out of official decisions. They alleged that the KP Governor, acting with mala fide intent and without jurisdiction, submitted a “tailor-made” report to the President, and that the proclamation was issued without regard to the guidelines in Articles 232 and 234.
They further contended that the KP government never reported any security emergency beyond its control, so the President’s unilateral action violated democratic norms and provincial autonomy. They also claimed that Article 232 prescribes a specific procedure and limits for proclaiming an emergency in a province, which the respondents did not follow.
On Friday, the joint opposition leadership of Tehreek-e-Tahaffuz-e-Ayeen-e-Pakistan also moved the PHC against the imposition of Governor’s Rule.
With the legal debate over the move’s constitutional validity continuing, attention now turns to the October 20 hearing and the positions the federal government and other respondents will take.